The technology bubble of the 1990s
(measured by the Nasdaq), the oil bubble of the late 1990s/early 2000s
(measured by oil futures prices), and the housing bubble (measured by the
S&P 500 Homebuilding Index) took 10 years and posted gains of about 1,000%
before they burst and quickly surrendered most of those gains.
However, we do not believe gold -- or
commodities in general -- is in a bubble and most likely will not continue to
track the classic pattern. But we do see potential for further modest gains for
precious metals and other commodities in 2011, to be accompanied by volatility.
The qualitative factors that are
combining to allow gold's shine to endure include the following:
1.
The declining dollar and outlook for rising U.S. inflation: The actions by the Fed to stimulate the economy have led to weakness in
the dollar. As the dollar goes down, the price of gold in dollars goes up.
While gold surged to an all-time high in dollar terms over the summer and fall
of 2010, gold has been flat over the same period in euros and in yen. In
Australian dollars, the peak in gold was back in February of 2009 and is down
about 10% since then. So part of our perception of the big surge in gold over
the past year is in large part because we are measuring it in weakening U.S.
dollars.
2.
Strong emerging market demand:
In China and India gold is both a savings vehicle and a luxury for an emerging
middle class. India and China lead the world in terms of gold demand growth.
3.
Central banks from sellers to buyers: The world's largest central banks have been
selling their gold reserves for decades after moving away from linking their
currencies to gold. Most recently, Mexico, Russia and Thailand added to their
gold reserves in February and March 2011. Given the current economic
environment, we believe central banks may continue to add to their gold reserve
base as further currency debasement and long-term inflation concerns persist. As
the reserve currency status of the dollar comes into question, emerging
economies are increasing their exposure to gold. With China and India holding
relatively low levels of gold, a modest increase in their holdings as a percent
of foreign reserves -- as they diversify away from holdings of U.S. Treasuries
-- could easily account for 100% of current annual production.
4.
Not just a defensive asset: Normally
a beneficiary of a pullback in riskier investments, investors have often
embraced gold as a perceived insurance policy against a return to recession.
However, rather than act purely as a defensive investment, gold rose last year
along side stocks and bonds.
5.
Supply has been constrained:
The supply-demand equation continues to provide a favorable tailwind for gold
prices. After averaging growth of 4% annually since 1980, world production
growth of gold has slowed considerably since 2001, averaging -1% annually over
the past 10 years. To meet the gradual rise in demand, a steady increase in
scrap supply has been needed. But scrap is falling short. It is getting more
expensive to mine gold as the most accessible areas have been mined out and new
mines are in increasingly remote or hard-to-mine locations. To meet the demand
the major producers are pursuing digs formerly thought to not be economically
viable at costs over $1,000 per ounce.
Finally, with gold supported by
multiple fundamental forces, one of our pre-conditions for a bubble is the
asset has to be "over-owned." All the gold produced around the world
over the past 110 years (which accounts for more than 80% of all gold ever
mined) at today's prices is equivalent to only about 3.9% of the combined total
value of stocks, bonds and cash around the world. While up from the 1.3% in
2000 when gold prices were depressed, it is similar to the 3.5% in 1990 and
well below the whopping 12.1% in 1980 when gold traded near its last peak.
While gold's popularity is returning, it does not seem "over-owned
Our site offers an outstanding analysis of the current state of gold and precious metals and their
prospects for the future. Check out the "Buy Gold and Silver" page for further information.